HeAvEnZcHiLd
Posts: 124
Joined: 6/1/2006
From: Australia
Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: congacon
do u even know what "concrete evidence" mean?
"negative review" and trash talking are not the same. his review is nothing but trash talking. when people give out a review they better make sure it is in a kind of constructive cricitism rather than trash talking.
if the sound was bad then he should have stated how so. eg. like poor arrangement, singers sang poorly, etc. that atmostphere was "dead", that sounded like he has attended a funeral rather than a musical show.
when did i called him a "asia's guerrilla"? did u understand the context of my comment? all i said was "I HOPE he is not an asia's guerrilla".
I don't know what YOU mean by "concrete evidence" but to me, in order to justify the term "concrete evidence", that evidence, so called, must be so conclusive as to be able to point to a specific plausible outcome.
The problem in relations to the attitudes displayed in this thread does not relate to whether the nature of the post are so called "negative review" or "trash talk". I'm speaking generally of anything which is in its nature "negative" which happens to pop up in these forums. You ask for your so called "concrete evidence" in relation to the "negative" aspects only. I don't mean to single out d.touch, but sorry, how come nobody asked for the so caleld "concrete evidence" in relation to why the show was good? Why was the stage simple but elegant? Why was the song requested good? That is not concrete evidence which points towards a good show. So why should the fan whom complained about the sound quality, being not up to standard in his opinion be forced to give your so called "concrete evidence" ?? The mind boggles :-)
One last thing, the points I mentioned in regards to alleging other fans as Asia's spies or guerillas or whatever it is that you choose to call it, is a general point. Just because they didn't like a show doesn't mean that they're acting for a competitor. It is COMPLETELY legitimate for a PBN fan to be disappointed with PBN. If, to be a PBN fan means to find absolutely every PBN product to be simply "the best", then there must be something very disturbed about the mindsets of so called PBN fans.
I don't mean to cause a war (or personally attack anyone, congacon). But judging from an objective point of few, I cannot help but speak up when I read this topic about the words pointed towards these people, who COULD just simply be disappointed in a PBN show anything nothing more.
|
Printable Version
Thuy Nga Paris By Night 92 - 
New Messages
No New Messages
Hot Topic w/ New Messages
Hot Topic w/o New Messages
Locked w/ New Messages
Locked w/o New Messages
Post New Thread